Independent agency in Peoria, Arizona. Strategic Insurance Agency Alliance member.

Call or text, a real person answers

602-480-6453

Personal insurance

Personal insurance for the way Arizona families actually live

Living in Peoria means balancing the beauty of desert living with the everyday risks that can affect your home, your vehicles and your financial wellbeing. Twelve lines of coverage, a growing list of carriers, and a local agent who will tell you which ones you actually need.

At a glance

The twelve personal lines

Almost everyone

Auto, and either homeowners, condo or renters.

Most households with a mortgage

Homeowners, plus a bundle discount on the auto.

Anyone with dependents

Life, usually term while the mortgage and the children are around.

Anyone with savings or equity

Umbrella, for liability above the auto and the home.

If you own the toys

Motorcycle, ATV and UTV, boat, RV.

Situational

Flood, SR-22 filing, loss assessment on a condo.

5.0 on Google and Facebook

A growing list of carriers

SIAA member agency

A local agent who picks up

Where to start

No two families share the exact same coverage needs

Most Arizona residents rely on multiple forms of insurance to protect their assets and provide peace of mind. Some coverage types are legally required, while others may be necessary under the terms of a mortgage, lease, or business agreement.

At Shield of Faith Insurance, we understand that no two families or individuals share the exact same coverage needs. That is why we offer a wide range of personal insurance policies in Peoria designed to safeguard against financial losses caused by accidents, natural disasters, theft, lawsuits, illness, and more. While it is impossible to eliminate every risk in life, having the right insurance plan can help minimize your exposure to unexpected costs and give you a stronger sense of security.

Our experienced team will take the time to understand your unique situation, explain your options in clear language, and provide customized solutions that fit your lifestyle and budget.

Personal insurance in Peoria, AZ, or personal lines insurance as the industry calls it, is simply the set of policies that protect a household rather than a business. Family insurance is not one product; it is whichever three or four of these actually apply to you. Personal insurance in Arizona also has its own local shape: roof age decides the home quote, monsoon run-off decides whether flood is worth pricing, and the commute decides the auto rate.

In practice most households need two or three of the twelve. The rest exist because somebody owns a boat, rents an apartment, bought a condo, or wants a layer of liability above everything else. We will tell you which group you are in on the first call.

How we work

What you get from a small local agency

01

Personalized service

You are not a policy number and you are not a lead in a queue. We ask what you own, who drives, and what a bad month would do to you, then build the coverage around that answer.

02

Honest advice and education

Before you are asked to buy anything, you get an explanation. What a deductible actually does. What the Arizona state minimum leaves uncovered. Where a cheaper policy got cheaper.

03

Coaching you to a lower rate

There are usually two or three levers on any policy: the deductible, the bundle, the driving record, the renewal date. We will walk you through which ones are worth pulling and which ones are not.

04

An agent who answers the phone

Call or text and a real person picks up, someone who knows your name and your policy. Not a call center script, not a callback ticket. Evenings and Saturdays are by appointment.

Shield of Faith Insurance

Independent agency, Peoria, AZ 85383

602-480-6453

The difference that matters

A captive agent sells you one company. We shop the field for your family.

It costs you nothing extra either way, which is the part most families never hear.

A captive agent

Represents a single insurance company and can only quote that company's rates.

When your renewal jumps, the options are a higher deductible or less coverage.

Switching carriers means starting over with a stranger at another agency.

The comparison shopping, if it happens at all, is yours to do.

+ moreTravelersLiberty MutualNationwideThe HartfordForemostBristol WestNational GeneralBranchStillwater

Shield of Faith, independent

Takes your one set of answers to every carrier that fits your household.

Reshops you at renewal when a carrier's rates move, without you asking.

Independent agents are paid by the carrier, so there is generally no extra cost to you.

One agent keeps the whole file: the cars, the house, the boat, the business.

No pressure, no runaround

How a quote works

1

Call or send the 60-second form

Reach out by phone or fill out the short quote form with a few basic details.

2

We compare carrier rates for you

We run your details across the top-rated carriers that write in your area and line up the coverage that fits your situation.

3

You pick the coverage, we handle the paperwork

Choose the option that works best for you and we take care of the paperwork from there.

Questions people actually ask

Frequently asked questions

Do I really need all of these policies?

Almost nobody needs all twelve. Most households need auto plus one of homeowners, condo or renters, and many should look at life and umbrella. The rest apply only if you own the thing they cover. We will tell you which ones you can skip, which is a shorter conversation than you might expect.

How does bundling work?

Bundling means holding two or more policies with the same carrier, which earns a multi-policy discount usually applied to both. It is normally the largest single discount available. It is not automatically cheaper, though, so we quote it bundled and split and compare the totals.

Can one agent really handle everything?

That is the whole point of an independent agency. The house, the cars, the boat, the umbrella and the business all sit in one file with one person who has read all of them. Coverage gaps mostly appear at the seams between two agencies who each assume the other has it.

Does it cost more to use an independent agent?

No. Independent agents are typically paid by the insurance carrier rather than by the client, so there is generally no extra cost. You get the carrier's rate plus a local agent comparing options on your behalf.

What if I already have an agent?

Then get a second opinion and see what it says. If your current coverage is good and priced well, we will tell you plainly, because a neighbor who leaves happy is worth more to us than a policy written badly.

Free and no obligation

Request your free insurance quote today

At Shield of Faith Insurance, we make it easy to compare options and find affordable coverage. Whether you need auto insurance, homeowners insurance, life insurance, or specialty coverage in Peoria, AZ, we're here to help.

Contact our Peoria office today to request your free, no-obligation insurance quote and discover how we can help you protect what matters most.

What happens next

1

A real person from our office calls you back with real numbers.

2

No robo-dialers and no spam calls.

3

You pick the coverage, we handle the paperwork.

The 60 second version

Tell us what you own and how to reach you. We will do the comparing.

No robo-dialers and no spam calls. A local agent follows up personally. Sending this does not bind coverage.

Map of the northwest Phoenix Valley showing Peoria, Glendale, Sun City, Surprise, Anthem and Wickenburg, drawn to scale

Service area

We proudly serve Peoria and the surrounding communities

We proudly serve Peoria and the surrounding communities, helping Arizona residents secure coverage that fits their lifestyles and budgets.

Peoria, AZ 85383
Office visits by appointment

Call or text anytime during the business week. Evenings and Saturdays by appointment.

In their words

What our neighbors say about working with us

5.0 stars across Google and Facebook

“

Great experience with this insurance agent! He helped me find a good price for my car insurance and made the whole process easy and stress-free. Very helpful, honest, and professional. Highly recommend!

RY

Ramez Y.

Google

I had a great experience with Shield of Faith Insurance! Mena took the time to understand our family's needs and explained each part of the coverage clearly. He helped us set up a home insurance policy with stronger protection and bundled it with our auto insurance for a package at a lower cost. What stood out most was his honesty and patience, he focused only on what truly benefited us, making the whole process simple and stress-free. We now have better coverage and peace of mind thanks to Mena. Highly recommend!

Hanna K. · Google and Facebook

Shield of Faith Insurance made getting renters insurance simple and affordable, after talking to a few other brokers, they were the ones who helped me get the best coverage with no stress!

Ahmad F. · Google and Facebook

I had a really good experience working with Shield of Faith Insurance. I needed new rental insurance as I was moving apartments. I got sent details on the policy next day and all I had to do was sign the forms. I ended up with a really good deal and saved about 20% compared to my old policy. I reached out to him again about auto insurance as well. I have had Geico for over 5 years and my premiums had only gotten more expensive. He somehow ended up getting me more coverage for half the price I was paying before. The entire process was easy and Mena was very responsive to email and text. Would highly encourage you to take a look and see what type of deals he can make for your insurance policies.

David G. · Google

I had a fantastic experience with Shield of Faith Insurance! Mena was incredibly patient and took the time to walk me through every detail of the coverage options. He made sure I understood the benefits clearly and only recommended what truly made sense for my specific situation. Thanks to Mena, I now have an auto policy that provides much better coverage at a significantly lower cost than what I was paying before. The entire process was smooth and efficient. He handled most of the backend work, which saved me a lot of time and hassle. If you're looking for an honest, knowledgeable, and helpful insurance agent, I highly recommend Mena at Shield of Faith Insurance!

Sara Z. · Google

Mena Michael was a saint in his approach and understanding. God bless this company and Mena for his outstanding service

Gevork N. · Google

Every review above is quoted in full from Google or Facebook. Read all of them.

Not sure which of these you need?

Call or text and describe your situation in your own words. We will sort out what applies to your family and what does not.